Dan Saffer has some good advice for people who want to be taken seriously when commenting in blogs.
He says that comments will not be taken seriously unless authors
follow a few simple rules:
- Use reasonable English grammar. Even if you don’t
speak English as your first language, you can at least obey some basic
English conventions, like capitalization and punctuation. Amazingly,
it is usually English-speakers who are the worst at this.- If you have a lot to say, break it up into
paragraphs. One giant paragraph is annoying.- Actually read what you’ve responded to. It’s amazing
how much misreading or skimming of a post people do before responding.
Closely read the post to see if your criticism or concern has already
been addressed.- Be reasonable when what you are responding to is
reasonable. Respond to reasonable discussions reasonably. Ignore
unreasonable discussions. (This is hard.)- Participate in the discussion. If you only post with
problems or to complain and never contribute solutions or interesting
commentary, you don’t have much credibility.- Don’t comment anonymously. If you believe what you
are saying, be an adult and put your name on it. If you are too
cowardly to leave your name, you probably shouldn’t be
commenting.
Stephen King said “write to your audience, everything else is bullsh*t”. It makes sense – write to the medium, and write to the reader (in this case both the blog owner who will moderate your comment as well as those that will read it further down the track).
I like to think of Dan’s advice as common sense – but who says that common sense is common?
This post was written by Andrew Boyd of Facibus on Blogging





9 users commented in " The Art of Successful Blog Commenting-By Andrew Boyd "
Follow-up comment rss or Leave a TrackbackSome very good advice in this article, I am going to link to it on my blog .
[...] Source [...]
I think your third point about actually reading the post is one that many, many people need to hear. Great, succinct advice, Andrew!
Nice Advices. Do you have any Idea of the paragraph formating in the comments files? It seems I can’t make any space or new paragraph properly although I have use “p” or put double “br” in each paragraph.
Everything seems to squeeze together after submitting the comments
If everyone followed these rules, the wold of blogging would be a lot easier to follow.
Blog on!
I think my favorite piece of advice here (although I am a total grammar nazi) is “Actually read what you’ve responded to.”
Just today I had someone come by a site of mine and it was pretty clear they’d just cut-and-pasted a comment they were passing around to all the sites writing on that subject, criticizing the usage of a particular word (which didn’t appear in my post).
Is it that hard to customize a comment, even if you must cut and paste?
Weekly Roundup – Week Ending June 20, 2007…
…
I like commenting on blog but never care about that rule
Great advice! Although it seems to start out with the premise that all the blogs in the universe are in the English language.
Instead of saying “Use reasonable grammar.” he writes “Use reasonable English grammar.”
Just my reminder that people do exist outside of the US ^^ Nice post anyway.
Leave A Reply